You may have read the guidelines from the FDA and EPA advocating for increased fish consumption, especially among pregnant women and young children. But there’s a catch to this tale—these recommendations don't dive deep enough into the complexities surrounding the safety and benefits of consuming seafood in today's world. Here are the five crucial things the authorities aren't telling you about the seafood on your plate.
  1. The Mercury Rising: Modern Findings on Low-Dose Exposure:  While the FDA and EPA acknowledge the neurodevelopmental benefits of fish consumption during pregnancy, they have largely glossed over new research about the risks of low-dose mercury exposure. Numerous studies over the last decade indicate that even slight elevations in prenatal mercury levels can have significant harmful effects on cognitive development.  The takeaway? Eating more fish can lead to smarter babies, but only if mercury intake is kept in check. There's a fine balance between the nutritional benefits and potential risks involved—fish consumption can be a double-edged sword.
  2. Outdated Guidelines: The Fuzzy Line Between "Safe" and "Unsafe" Mercury Levels: The EPA's "reference dose" for mercury ingestion dates back to 1999. Given the mounting evidence suggesting that even low doses of mercury can have adverse health effects, it's high time to reevaluate these guidelines. Some experts believe the current recommended limits for mercury exposure are at least 50% too high. If you're eating 12 ounces of seafood a week, you'd need to pick options with very low mercury levels to be within the truly safe range.
  3. The Incomplete List: More Than Just Eating "More Fish".  The advice to "eat more fish" is too simplistic. Mercury levels and omega-3 fatty acids differ drastically between fish species. While some are touted as "lower mercury" options, the reality is that not all these recommendations hold water. For example, canned light tuna and cod aren't low in mercury, and many low-mercury options like tilapia are actually poor in beneficial omega-3s.
  4. The Tuna Trap: A Fishy Tale.  More than one-third of Americans' exposure to mercury comes from tuna. Despite this, guidelines continue to categorize light tuna as a "low-mercury" option and suggest that a weekly 6-ounce serving of albacore tuna is safe. But the truth is, even one such serving significantly exceeds the EPA’s safe limit. Tuna, it turns out, isn't the wholesome choice we’ve been led to believe.
  5. The Frequent Fish Eater's Dilemma:  About 5% of Americans already exceed the recommended fish intake of 8-to-12 ounces per week, and around 10% of women of childbearing age have elevated blood mercury levels. These guidelines don't provide adequate advice for those who frequently consume seafood. Such individuals, especially women and young children, need precise information on which seafood options have the least mercury content.

Your Safe Harbor: Choose Seatopia

In the murky waters of seafood safety, Seatopia offers a beacon of clarity. We provide artisan, farm-raised seafood that undergoes rigorous testing for mercury levels. Sourced through regenerative aquaculture practices and backed by functional medicine doctors, Seatopia is the go-to choice for discerning consumers.

Be part of the sea change. Choose Seatopia for a healthier, happier, and more sustainable you.


*This blog is intended to offer information and encourage a conversation about seafood safety. For personalized health advice, consult your healthcare provider.*

Related Article

Blog posts from aquaculture blog

Selenium: Nature’s Antidote to Mercury — And What It Tells Us About the Seafood We Evolved to Eat - SEATOPIA

Selenium: Nature’s Antidote to Mercury — And What It Tells Us About the Seafood We Evolved to Eat

Long before “superfoods” were a trend, seafood was humanity’s original nutrient intelligence system. Our ancestors lived in intimate connection with the coast — gathering shellfish, crabs, seaweed, and small coastal fish from tidal pools and estuaries. These foods provided abundant selenium, iodine,...

Read more

The Surprising Truth About Seafood Packaging (and Why Ours Matters) - SEATOPIA

The Surprising Truth About Seafood Packaging (and Why Ours Matters)

When it comes to regenerative seafood, every detail matters. It’s not just about what’s on your plate — it’s about how it got there, how it was raised, how it was preserved, and what kind of ripple effect it leaves...

Read more

Is Your Sushi Safe? Why the Original Superfood Needs a Modern Clean Label - SEATOPIA

Is Your Sushi Safe? Why the Original Superfood Needs a Modern Clean Label

Sushi-grade isn’t a guarantee — it’s a starting point. Learn how Seatopia is redefining clean seafood through lab-verified purity, mercury and microplastic testing, and super-frozen transparency.

Read more

Why Sushi-Grade Seafood May Be Better Than Your Omega-3 Supplement - SEATOPIA

Why Sushi-Grade Seafood May Be Better Than Your Omega-3 Supplement

Drop the Supplements - Discover the pro-resolving compounds in Seatopia fish that help your body heal naturally.

Read more

Introducing the Seatopia Trout Dog: Seafood, Reimagined - SEATOPIA

Introducing the Seatopia Trout Dog: Seafood, Reimagined

At Seatopia, our mission is to connect families with the cleanest, most nutrient-dense seafood raised on regenerative farms. That’s why we’re thrilled to share Trout Dogs, a unique creation from our longtime partners at McFarland Springs Trout Farm—the pioneering regenerative aquaculture farm in Northern California that sets the gold standard for eco-friendly trout.

Read more

The Seatopia Standard™: Redefining Clean, Regenerative Seafood - SEATOPIA

The Seatopia Standard™: Redefining Clean, Regenerative Seafood

we created the Seatopia Standard™ to redefine what “clean seafood” really means: mercury-safe, free of detectable microplastics, nutrient-dense, and sourced only from farms committed to regeneration. Unlike the status quo, our seafood is lab-tested, traceable, and raised with practices that heal oceans instead of depleting them. By 2035, our goal is to capture 1% of U.S. seafood sales—proving that Regenerative Aquaculture 3.0 is scalable and igniting a movement that restores health and abundance to the blue planet.

Read more

From Sustainability to Self: How the Ocean Taught Me That Food Is Medicine - SEATOPIA

From Sustainability to Self: How the Ocean Taught Me That Food Is Medicine

🌕 Sturgeon Moon Reflections – A Portal for Nourishment & Change

This August, the Sturgeon Moon rises in the glow of the Lion’s Gate Portal—an ancient astronomical alignment of the Earth, Sun, Sirius, and Orion’s Belt. In many traditions, this is a time for vision, renewal, and aligning our choices with the future we wish to create.

For Seatopia, it’s a reminder that personal nourishment and planetary regeneration are inseparable.

Our founder, James Arthur, shares how his journey from sustainable seafood advocate to food-as-medicine advocate revealed a deeper truth: focusing on clean, nutrient-dense seafood not only transforms human health—it accelerates the shift to regenerative aquaculture that heals our oceans.

📖 Read the full story →

And if you’re looking to mark this rare alignment with something sacred at your table, consider:
💎 Salmon Roe (Caviar) – Nature’s Multivitamin →
Revered by traditional cultures, rich in DHA, EPA, and micronutrients, and sourced from farms that restore marine ecosystems.


🌕 Only 54 Full Moons Until 2030. Each one is a chance to realign—with nature, with nourishment, and with the future you want to see.

Read more

A Milestone in Ocean Regeneration: Celebrating 20,000 Kelp Trees Planted - SEATOPIA

A Milestone in Ocean Regeneration: Celebrating 20,000 Kelp Trees Planted

Celebrating 20,000 Kelp Trees Planted for Ocean Regeneration
Thanks to the Seatopia community, we've planted over 20,000 kelp trees in British Columbia, creating a thriving kelp forest that supports marine life, improves water quality, and helps offset ocean acidification. This milestone is just the beginning—together, we're regenerating our oceans, one kelp tree at a time.

Read more